87.7% of F&O Traders Lost Money in FY26: What 2026 Research Shows About Trader Behaviour
Three recent developments show retail trading behaviour from different angles: what traders did in a sharp sell-off, how their sentiment is now being measured, and how losses accumulate over several years. On 5 November 2026, US retail investors sold more single stocks in one day than at any time since March 2020, according to Vanda Research data reported by CNBC. On 12 November 2026, the European Central Bank (ECB) published a blog on an AI-based indicator that reads retail investor sentiment from Reddit. A Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) study of the 2025–26 financial year (FY26), reported by Outlook Business and Outlook Money on 21 August 2026, found that most individual derivatives traders keep losing money even as they gain experience. Academic work published in 2026 on the disposition effect and loss aversion helps explain why these patterns persist.
The first signal is a break in familiar "buy-the-dip" behaviour. Vanda Research data reported by CNBC show retail investors sold a net $338 million of single stocks on Thursday, 5 November 2026. That was the largest one-day outflow since March 2020, when retail investors pulled $502 million. The selling came during a broad technology sell-off in which the Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 1,800 points and the Nasdaq Composite dropped into a correction. Initial reports put the figure at $265 million; later reports revised it to $338 million (Yahoo Finance). Vanda's note observed that in a typical sell-off "retail buy the dip," but this time "that bid has effectively disappeared from individual names."
| Measure (Vanda Research) | Value | Date |
|---|---|---|
| Net retail selling, single US stocks | $338m (first reported as $265m) | 5 Nov 2026 |
| Previous record one-day outflow | $502m | March 2020 |
| Net selling earlier that afternoon | About one-third higher than at the close, before late-session buyers stepped in | 5 Nov 2026 |
Not all retail activity on that day was selling. Vanda said the buying that remained was concentrated in leveraged ETFs: the ProShares UltraPro QQQ (TQQQ), which aims to deliver three times the daily performance of the Nasdaq-100, and the Direxion Daily Semiconductor Bull 3X Shares (SOXL). Individual stocks were being sold while risk was being added through geared products. Viraj Patel, global macro strategist at Vanda, called the session "a total capitulation by retail investors" and linked it to a wider "buyers' strike" among institutional investors, alongside forced selling by systematic and leveraged strategies (Yahoo Finance, 6 November 2026). From a behavioural standpoint, the combination of de-risking in single names and re-risking through leverage is a pattern worth recognising in one's own records.
The ECB's 12 November 2026 blog, "Reading the room: what Reddit tells us about retail investor sentiment," states that retail investors are "increasingly becoming speculative traders." It describes an AI-based Reddit indicator (R-RISI) that converts retail discussion into a short-term market signal. The ECB tracks the 365-day rolling correlation between net retail sentiment and price movements, and presents the tool as a way for central banks to obtain timely insight into how a more speculative group of retail investors reacts to markets. The methodology is set out in ECB Working Paper No. 3276 (August 2026). For behavioural analysts, the significance is that what traders say about markets now sits alongside their trades and order flow as an observable data source.
India's derivatives market supplies the clearest multi-year evidence. According to Outlook Business's coverage of SEBI's FY26 study of equity futures and options (F&O), 87.7% of individual F&O traders lost money in FY26, only slightly lower than the 90.9% recorded in FY25. Aggregate individual losses reached ₹91,685 crore, even though the number of active individual traders fell sharply after tighter regulation. These figures come from press coverage of the study rather than the SEBI report itself.
| SEBI FY26 equity derivatives study (as reported) | Value |
|---|---|
| Individual traders with losses, FY26 | 87.7% |
| Individual traders with losses, FY25 | 90.9% |
| Aggregate individual losses, FY26 | ₹91,685 crore |
| Loss-makers among first-year traders | About 91% |
| Loss-makers among traders with 4+ consecutive years | Over 95% |
| Five-year traders with no losing years | 0.5% |
| Traders with mixed quarters whose average quarterly loss exceeded average quarterly gain | About 79% |
| Loss-makers among traders with no equity holdings | About 93% |
| Loss-makers among traders with equity portfolios above ₹10 crore | 58% |
The study found that experience did not meaningfully improve outcomes. The share of loss-makers rose from about 91% among first-year traders to over 95% among those with four or more consecutive years in the market, and only 0.5% of five-year traders had no losing years. SEBI described losses as "highly persistent among continuing traders," and larger losses often did not lead traders to exit (Outlook Money). The quarterly asymmetry is particularly relevant to risk management: for about 79% of traders who recorded both gaining and losing quarters, the average loss was larger than the average gain. That pattern is consistent with allowing losses to run while closing gains early.
That asymmetry has a well-documented name: the disposition effect, the tendency to sell winning positions too soon and hold losing ones too long. Research presented at the American Finance Association meetings in 2026 (Yeung et al., "Navigating through fear and greed: The experience-driven disposition effect"), as summarised by Evidence Investor, tracked 189,530 Chinese retail investors and more than 40 million trades through the 2013–2016 boom and bust. On average, investors were 2.67 percentage points more likely to sell a winning position than a losing one. Past losses strengthened the effect by about 10%, while past gains weakened it by roughly the same amount. Commentators described this as a "doom loop," in which the investors already losing money repeat the error more often.
The bias is visible not only in which positions are closed but in how orders are placed. A September 2026 paper in the Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Finance by De Winne, Luong and Palan combined a laboratory experiment with 2003–2021 account data from a Belgian online broker. It found that investors with a strong disposition effect rely more heavily on their purchase price when setting sell orders. The authors conclude that the bias appears "not only in whether investors sell but also in how they sell." Order-level records, including order types, limit prices and their distance from entry prices, can therefore serve as diagnostic evidence alongside completed trades.
How strong is loss aversion in practice? A January 2026 paper in the Journal of Risk and Uncertainty (Emami Namini and Kapoor) measured it in real business decisions rather than trading. Using labour-hiring decisions at a retail chain, it estimated a loss aversion coefficient (λ) of 4.2, which rose to 9.5 on slow days with smaller management teams and disappeared on busy days. In structured interviews with business owners and managers, the mean λ was 10.1 and the median 1.6; 74% had coefficients above 1 and 30% above 3. A coefficient above 1 means losses are weighted more heavily than equivalent gains. The setting is not financial markets, but the study suggests loss aversion intensifies when decision-makers are under-stretched and subject to fewer checks.
Trading frequency also reflects the environment in which decisions are made. The UK Financial Conduct Authority's Occasional Paper 66 (first published April 2025, updated 3 June 2026) linked trading records from mobile investment platforms with users' credit files. Users of apps with heavy "digital engagement practices" were more likely to be younger and male, to engage more with the app, to trade more often, to be in financial distress, and to show "elevated, erratic, or concerning trading behaviour." The FCA reported an association between using these apps and poor financial outcomes, indicating that overtrading can reflect platform design as well as individual choice.
Regulatory loss-rate data provide benchmarks for leveraged products. When ESMA introduced its measures on contracts for difference (CFDs), it cited national regulators' analyses showing that 74–89% of retail CFD accounts typically lose money, with average losses per client of €1,600 to €29,000 (CMS). A review by The Investors Centre of the mandatory risk warnings published by 14 FCA-authorised CFD brokers, as of April 2026, found a mean loss-making share of 70.0% and a median of 71.0%. UK firms must disclose their own rolling 12-month figure, while new firms without 12 months of data must use the 74–89% range.
| Market and measure | Value | Source and date |
|---|---|---|
| EU retail CFD accounts losing money | 74–89% | ESMA (2018 measures) |
| EU average loss per client | €1,600–€29,000 | ESMA (2018 measures) |
| UK CFD broker disclosures (n=14) | 70.0% mean / 71.0% median | The Investors Centre, April 2026 |
| India individual F&O traders losing money | 87.7% | SEBI, FY26 (as reported) |
Taken together, these studies point to specific, measurable signals in a trader's own records. The first is the size of average losses relative to average gains, the measure behind SEBI's 79% finding. The second is holding time: whether losing positions remain open longer than winning ones, the pattern quantified in the AFA 2026 study. The third is order behaviour: whether sell orders cluster around purchase prices, as the Belgian broker study found. The fourth is behaviour under stress: whether leverage increases during sell-offs, as Vanda observed on 5 November 2026.
In this framework, consistency means these measures remain stable across market conditions, and discipline means they do not deteriorate after a run of losses, the condition under which the AFA 2026 research found the disposition effect strengthens. Data quality is equally important. The JBEF authors note that limit-order mechanics can bias measures of the disposition effect, and the SEBI and FCA findings rest on large, linked datasets. Complete, time-stamped records of orders as well as trades are a prerequisite for any reliable conclusion about behaviour.
This article is for information only and does not constitute investment advice or a recommendation regarding any security.
Key points
- Vanda Research data reported by CNBC show US retail investors sold a net $338 million of single stocks on 5 November 2026, the largest one-day outflow since March 2020 ($502 million), while remaining buying concentrated in leveraged ETFs such as TQQQ and SOXL.
- As reported by Outlook Business, SEBI's FY26 study found 87.7% of individual F&O traders lost money (90.9% in FY25), with aggregate losses of ₹91,685 crore; about 79% of traders with mixed quarters had average losses larger than average gains.
- Research presented at AFA 2026 (Yeung et al.) found a 2.67 percentage point disposition effect across 189,530 investors, strengthening by about 10% after past losses.
- A September 2026 JBEF study found investors with a strong disposition effect anchor sell orders on purchase price, making order-level data a behavioural diagnostic.
- The ECB's Reddit-based R-RISI indicator and the FCA's Occasional Paper 66 show that sentiment and app engagement are now measurable components of trader behaviour.
- Outlook Business, Nearly 90% Retail F&O Traders Lost Money In FY26. Why Do They Keep Coming Back?, August 21, 2026
- Outlook Money, Sebi Study Finds F&O Traders Don’t Necessarily Get Better With Experience, August 21, 2026
- CNBC, Retail traders dump the most stocks in a single day since Covid selloff, November 5, 2026
- Yahoo Finance, Retail traders dump $338 million in stocks in biggest selling day since 2020, November 6, 2026
- Yahoo Finance, Retail traders dump $265 million in stocks in biggest selling day since 2020
- European Central Bank, Reading the room: what Reddit tells us about retail investor sentiment, November 12, 2026
- Evidence Investor, The disposition effect: why losing investors keep getting worse
- Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Finance (ScienceDirect), Retail investors’ disposition effect and order choices, September 2026
- Journal of Risk and Uncertainty (Springer), Does exposure to losses intensify loss aversion? Evidence from a competitive industry, January 2026
- Financial Conduct Authority, Occasional Paper 66: Playing the market: a behavioural data analysis of digital engagement practices and investment outcomes, June 3, 2026
- CMS, ESMA/FCA measures on the provision of contracts for differences and binary options to retail investors in the EU
- The Investors Centre, UK CFD Trading Statistics 2026 — 14 Brokers Compared
